HimCare controversy returns to Assembly as Janak Raj challenges HP CM Sukhu to prove surgical allegation
BJP MLA offers to resign if four allegedly irregular operations are traced to him; demands resignation of entire Cabinet if Chief Minister fails to substantiate charge
DHARAMSHALA/SHIMLA: The controversy surrounding alleged irregularities in the HimCare health insurance scheme has returned to the centre of political confrontation in Himachal Pradesh, with Bharmaur BJP MLA Dr Janak Raj challenging Chief Minister Sukhvinder Singh Sukhu to substantiate his allegations concerning four men whose medical records allegedly showed operations involving the uterus.
In a dramatic intervention in the Vidhan Sabha, Dr Janak Raj, a neurosurgeon by profession and former Medical Superintendent, Bharmour, offered to resign from his Assembly membership before the next Assembly session if the government establishes that he performed the four disputed operations.
In a counter-challenge, he demanded that the Chief Minister and the entire Cabinet resign if the government fails to prove its allegation.
The challenge has raised the stakes in an increasingly bitter political battle over HimCare, a state-funded health insurance programme originally intended to extend cashless medical treatment to families not covered under Ayushman Bharat or government medical reimbursement facilities.
Four cases and the question of who performed the operations
Dr Janak Raj's intervention was significant because he sought to distinguish between a medical procedure, a billing entry and the doctor or hospital responsible for it.
According to the account he placed before the House, two of the four disputed cases related to February 21 and April 26, 2023, when the Congress government was already in office. He argued that the allegations could not automatically be attributed to him merely because he had held an administrative position at IGMC.
He also maintained that a Medical Superintendent does not operate the login credentials used for processing claims under HimCare and Ayushman Bharat.
The MLA cited the possibility of erroneous gender entries in the records and argued that the disputed entries should not be equated with actual operations.
He further pointed out that biological males can, in rare circumstances, have a uterus, making medical verification essential before drawing conclusions from gender fields in a database.
The controversy had earlier acquired another dimension when Dr Janak Raj furnished RTI responses from IGMC Shimla, Kamla Nehru Hospital and Dr Rajendra Prasad Medical College, Tanda.
The responses reportedly stated that these institutions had no records of uterine removal operations performed on male patients between 2019 and 2022. However, those responses need to be read alongside the specific disputed records and their dates; they do not, by themselves, settle the four cases now being discussed.
Sukhu had raised the issue
in the House in 2025
The controversy has its roots in the Chief Minister's repeated assertions that HimCare had been compromised by financial irregularities during the previous BJP government led by Jai Ram Thakur.
On December 5, 2025, while responding to questions during the winter session at Tapovan, Sukhu said the government would conduct a detailed inquiry into alleged excess reimbursements and undue benefits given to private hospitals and medical shops.
He informed the Assembly that expenditure under HimCare was being audited by the Principal Accountant General, Himachal Pradesh. He also said that the scheme's original purpose had been compromised by corruption, although treatment for poor and needy patients would continue.
The Chief Minister disclosed that private hospitals had received ₹211.27 crore under HimCare during the preceding three years, up to October 31, 2025. BJP legislators, meanwhile, demanded that the government disclose the names of institutions allegedly involved in irregularities rather than making general accusations against the previous regime.
The issue flared further during the March 2026 Budget Session when Sukhu referred to internal audit findings concerning bills for ovarian operations on male patients and expired intraocular lenses being implanted in patients.
He initially referred to irregularities of ₹1,100 crore, but subsequently clarified that this was the total expenditure under the scheme and that the amount under scrutiny was approximately ₹100–110 crore. He still needs to clear the air.
The Chief Minister ordered a vigilance investigation and said the government intended to plug loopholes rather than discontinue the scheme.
In April 2026, the State Vigilance and Anti-Corruption Bureau constituted an eight-member Special Investigation Team headed by IG Bimal Gupta to investigate the alleged irregularities. The investigation was intended to examine suspected fraudulent billing and financial transactions under the scheme.
HimCare: The benefits,
beneficiaries and financial questions
The Himachal Health Care Scheme, popularly known as HimCare, was launched on January 1, 2019, by the previous BJP government. It provides cashless treatment of up to ₹5 lakh per family annually in empanelled hospitals.
Importantly, the scheme was designed for families not covered under Ayushman Bharat or government medical reimbursement arrangements. Its eligibility therefore extends beyond the conventional BPL category. It was intended to provide financial protection to households otherwise excluded from publicly funded health insurance.
The Himachal Pradesh Economic Survey 2025–26, which includes the National Health Mission's programme data, provides the following figures. HimCare performance since inception: 4.39 lakh Families registered, 1.04 lakh Beneficiaries treated. ₹142.18 cr is Treatment expenditure and ₹5 lakh is Annual family coverage.
These figures underline why the controversy cannot be reduced to a political confrontation between the Congress and BJP. More than four lakh registered families have a stake in the continuity and credibility of the scheme.
There is also a substantial
difference between the number
of registered families and
the number of beneficiaries who have actually availed treatment. The government needs to explain the utilisation pattern, claims approved, claims rejected, payments released and outstanding liabilities.
The mounting liability towards hospital
The financial sustainability of
HimCare has become another major
concern. In April 2025,
PGIMER Chandigarh had reportedly
submitted 1,478 claims amounting
to approximately ₹143 crore to the Himachal government, which remained unpaid. The institute had an agreement with the state government for settlement of claims within a month.
In November 2025, the Kangra District Private Hospital Doctors Association claimed that more than ₹356 crore in combined liabilities under HimCare and Ayushman Bharat were pending towards private hospitals across the state. This was an association's claim, not an audited government figure.
During the March 2026 Assembly proceedings, Health Minister Dhani Ram Shandil disclosed outstanding liabilities of ₹391.27 crore towards hospitals associated with HimCare. He also stated that 4.33 lakh families were covered under the scheme.
The continued accumulation of unpaid claims raises a serious question: while the government is investigating alleged fraud, what mechanism has been put in place to ensure that genuine hospitals and patients do not suffer?
Renewal restrictions
and the future of the scheme
The state government amended HimCare provisions through a notification dated June 24, 2025.
Under the amended arrangements, fresh registration and preparation of new beneficiary cards during March, June, September and December were allowed for a one-year policy period. Beneficiaries were also required to give an undertaking that no family member was covered under government reimbursement schemes for employees and pensioners.
The change towards a one-year policy period and periodic renewal has increased the importance of timely renewal, continuity of treatment and clear communication with beneficiaries.
The government must explain how existing patients undergoing prolonged treatment will be protected, how hospitals will receive their outstanding payments and whether the renewal process is creating difficulties for families dependent on the scheme.
The Himachal Pradesh Swasthya Bima Yojana Society, which administers the scheme, provides facilities for card renewal, checking beneficiary status and locating empanelled hospitals through its official portal.
The larger issue:
Accountability, not political
point-scoring
The latest confrontation has brought the focus back to the fundamental question of accountability in the administration of a publicly funded healthcare programme.
If the disputed records were generated through incorrect gender entries, the government must establish who entered the data, who verified it, who authorised the claim and whether any payment was actually released against those entries.
If surgeries were genuinely performed, the names of the operating surgeons, hospital records, discharge summaries, operative notes, patient identities and payment trail must be examined.
Equally, the government must establish whether the alleged irregularities occurred during the BJP government's tenure, the Congress government's tenure or across both periods.
Dr Janak Raj's challenge has made this demand for documentary evidence even more pressing. His offer to resign and his demand for the resignation of the entire Cabinet if the allegations cannot be established have turned the controversy into a test of political credibility.
A sitting High Court or Supreme Court judge-led inquiry, as sought by the MLA, would provide an opportunity to establish the facts independently of the political positions taken by either side.
The government cannot expect the public to accept allegations as established facts merely because an internal audit has flagged suspicious entries. Equally, the Opposition cannot dismiss an investigation without accounting for the records and financial transactions under scrutiny.
The immediate responsibility rests with the government to place the audit findings, SIT investigation status, hospital-wise claims and supporting medical records in the public domain, while protecting patient confidentiality.
The credibility of HimCare and the interests of its beneficiaries must not become collateral damage in the continuing Congress-BJP political battle.
#HimCare #HimachalPradesh #JanakRaj #SukhvinderSinghSukhu
