Saturday - November 21, 2026

Weather: 15°C

English Hindi

REGD.-HP-09-0015257

Facebook Twitter Whatsapp Insta Email Print
  • By KULDEEP CHAUHAN, EDITOR-IN-CHIEF, This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

‘Breakdown’ Excuse Falls Flat as Shimla MC Pushes ₹1.40 Crore Vehicle Proposals

SHIMLA: The Shimla Municipal Corporation’s (SMC) attempt to justify a fresh round of vehicle purchases by citing "frequent breakdowns" and "rising maintenance costs" has found few takers among residents and civic observers, who see the explanation as only half the truth—a convenient narrative packaged for public consumption rather than a genuine operational necessity.

At the centre of the row are proposals tabled before the SMC’s Finance, Contract, and Planning Committee (FC & PC) carrying a combined figure of ₹1,40,95,384 (over ₹1.40 crore) across six listed options.

Five of those options—totalling ₹1,32,21,764 on paper, topped by a ₹36,68,640 Toyota Innova Hycross—have been placed for replacing Mayor Surinder Chauhan’s 2019 Mahindra Scorpio S11 (HP07E-2200), alongside an ₹8,73,620 Mahindra Bolero Neo proposed for the Executive Engineer.

Even pairing the single costliest option for the Mayor with the Executive Engineer’s vehicle pushes the bill to ₹45,42,260.

While the official memorandum for the Mayor’s vehicle blames hilly terrain, repeated repairs, and disruption of official engagements, critics point to an obvious contradiction: numerous government and civic vehicles from 2010 and 2016 models continue to ply smoothly across the same steep Shimla roads without needing premature replacement.

 By contrast, the Mayor’s Scorpio is a 2019 model—barely seven years old and nowhere near the mandatory 15-year government scrapping threshold that applies to the Executive Engineer’s older vehicle (HP07A-0744), which completes 15 years on January 17, 2027.

For a corporation that survives heavily on state grants amid the Sukhu government’s financial crunch, the contrast between official excuses and ground reality is stark.

 While the Mayor and his team line up swanky rides, ordinary residents across Sanjauli, Panthaghati, BCS, the Sabzi Mandis, IGMC, and around the HP Lift continue to navigate potholed, dust-choked roads, traffic snarls, and roadside encroachments—alongside overflowing garbage, clogged drains, and stinking public toilets that have dragged Shimla down in Swachh Survekshan over the past three-plus years.

Having watched grand publicity drives, hoardings, and boards rolled out at public expense without matching improvements on the streets, Shimla’s citizens are keeping their cards close to their chest.

To most onlookers, neither the glossy PR campaigns nor the "breakdown" alibi holds water—leaving the Mayor and the municipal establishment squarely on the spot over where public money is actually going.

#ShimlaMC #SurinderChauhan #CivicFailure #PublicMoney

Latest Stories
Nov 18
HP VIGILANCE CAUGHT POLICE SUB-INSPECTOR RED-HANDED WITH Rs 20000 BRIBE

HIMACHAL PRADESH VIGILANCE CRACKS DOWN ON EXTORTIO...

Nov 17
Jobs in HP Police Department; Here is What Candidates Need to Do

Himachal Pradesh Police Constable Recruitment 2026...